Interior Secretary Recommends Shrinking Bears Ears

Monument review includes oceans tribal lands and Sequoias

Monument review includes oceans tribal lands and Sequoias

Following up on an executive order, Interior Secretary Ryan Zinke has recommended President Donald Trump review the boundaries of the Bears Ears National Monument in Utah, which was created by former President Barack Obama.

In April, President Donald Trump signed an executive order directing Zinke to review national monuments of more than 100,000 acres designated since 1996, saying some of them amounted to a "massive federal land grab".

Despite the almost unanimous sentiment among the general public who commented, Zinke chose to ignore the findings entirely in his official report to the president and instead pointed to the handful of comments received from industry-friendly Utah politicians who oppose Bears Ears to justify his bold recommendations. Zinke's recommendations, announced Monday, add fuel to the controversy over the Utah monument, which President Obama designated during his final days in office.

The Navajo Nation and Hopi and Ute tribes pushed for the Bears Ears declaration, and said it would help protect cultural and sacred sites.

Rather than designating a vast monument, as Obama did, "it would have been more appropriate to identify and separate the areas that have significant objects to be protected to meet the purposes of the Act", Zinke's report said. He also suggests working with Congress to enable Native American tribes to co-manage cultural areas. This week Zinke travels to ME to review their new National Monument, let's hope his next trip isn't to Southern Oregon.

"Secretary Zinke's recommendation that the President shrink the boundaries of Bears Ears National Monument ignores the law and public outcry, including over one million comments in support of monument status", Patagonia CEO Rose Marcario said in response to the Zinke's decision. The preliminary report is the first step of a larger review of more than two dozen national monuments that protect US public lands, mostly in the West.

Grijalva said Zinke's memo makes no mention of public comments on the property and does not "reference any maps or specify legislative language".

The review also targets five marine monuments in the Atlantic and Pacific oceans.

"Attempting to remove protections for public lands by diminishing a national monument would be unprecedented in the modern era and may jeopardize other monuments", said Corey Fisher, senior public policy director for Trout Unlimited's Sportsmen's Conservation Project.

But supporters say the act is necessary to protect threatened lands - and that "right-sizing" a designated monument has happened only on handful of times since the act was created in 1906. Not only is this entire national monument review process unnecessary and a waste of taxpayer dollars, President Trump does not have the legal authority to act on these recommendations. No president has ever attempted to revoke a national monument. "The man charged with protecting public lands just told the public their voices don't count". "The monument will be managed in cooperation with the tribes".

Part One of our conversation about Secretary Zinke's Bears Ears recommendation.

Recommended News

  • N.Korea frees student in coma after high-level U.S.  visit

    N.Korea frees student in coma after high-level U.S. visit

    Anyone wanting to own a larger-than-life Kim will have to await the end of North Korea's nuclear program. But Anna Fifield says, this time , the North had appeared unwilling to bargain.

    Focus Brexit on economy, Scottish Conservatives urge British PM

    Ms Davidson is also among Tories raising concerns about Ms May's potential partner, the DUP, and the party's record on gay rights. But the Conservatives failed to win 326 seats in the general election - the number needed to have an outright majority.

    Bill Cosby jury quits for the night, no verdict

    The entertainer did not take the stand at his trial, but prosecutors used his deposition testimony as evidence. Bill Cosby has arrived at the courthouse for the second day of jury deliberations in his sexual assault trial.
  • 'Softer' Brexit on the Horizon, UK Businesses Breathe Sigh of Relief

    'Softer' Brexit on the Horizon, UK Businesses Breathe Sigh of Relief

    A senior member of the Democratic Unionist Party has declared that "the future's Orange" as it stood on the brink of a deal to allow Theresa May to stay in power.

    Georgia manhunt: Authorities identify 2 slain prison guards

    Curtis Billue , 58, had been a guard since 2007 and Christopher Monica , 42, joined the department in 2009. Authorities are searching for two inmates, 43-year-old Donnie Russell Rowe and 24-year-old Ricky Dubose .
    Mattis blames Congress for poor state of US combat readiness

    Mattis blames Congress for poor state of US combat readiness

    Afghan security personnel arrive at the site of a motorcycle bomb explosion in front of the Jami Mosque in Herat on June 6, 2017. This is 11 percent less than the military held around the same time in 2016.
  • Video shows Penn State frat pledge in agony after fall

    Scicchitano confirmed that at no point during this time did any of the fraternity members attempt to render aid or call 911. Jim Piazza held his head in his hands and sobbed as prosecutors showed pictures of his son in the hospital.

    Pentagon Chief Jim Mattis 'shocked' by low level of US military readiness

    Mattis, the former commander of all Middle East wars, said yesterday that the U.S. is not winning the war in Afghanistan. Officials were investigating whether they were killed by friendly fire in the opening minutes of the three-hour battle.
    Talks between Theresa May and DUP 'going well'

    Talks between Theresa May and DUP 'going well'

    May wants to pull Britain out of the single market, largely to control immigration, and then negotiate a trade deal with the EU. Ms May appeared contrite, sought to apologise for her failed election gamble and gave an explanation of what went wrong.
  • Heated exchange between Sen. Wyden, Attorney General Sessions

    On Tuesday, Attorney General Sessions insisted his response to Franken, when viewed in context, was accurate. He has acknowledged two meetings a year ago with Russia's ambassador to the U.S., Sergei Kislyak .
    German Chancellor Angela Merkel urges swift Brexit talks after United Kingdom  vote

    German Chancellor Angela Merkel urges swift Brexit talks after United Kingdom vote

    The Protestant unionist party also had links with outlawed paramilitary groups during the years of Northern Ireland's "Troubles". The party's opposition to abortion and same-sex marriage places it at odds with modernizing Conservatives.

    Sessions vows to defend himself against 'false allegations'

    If the event is an open hearing, Sessions's appearance would be the second Big Day before the Senate committee in as many weeks. Trump has suggested there might be tapes of his encounters with Comey; Comey said last week that "lordy" he hopes there are.

We are pleased to provide this opportunity to share information, experiences and observations about what's in the news.
Some of the comments may be reprinted elsewhere in the site or in the newspaper.
Thank you for taking the time to offer your thoughts.